Monday, February 25, 2008

AND SO IT BEGINS AGAIN...


AN ILL-ADVISED LOOK AHEAD AT SOME POTENTIAL PLAYERS IN AWARDS SEASON 2008

Nobody is more ready than I am to put the 2007 awards season in the rearview mirror... and nobody is more anxious for the 2008 awards season to begin, either!

At this time, we obviously have very little information upon which to base any discussion of what the awards landscape may look likenot only have none us seen the films, but some of them have not yet even gone into production! That being said, one can—and many do—venture an 'educated guess' as to what and who some of the prime suspects may be by considering a few key criteria of a film, or what I like to call its 'pedigree': (1) release date, (2) subject matter, (3) on-screen and behind-the-scenes talent, (4) historical precedent, (5) buzz about and excitement for its release.

Clearly, this 'formula' is anything but fool-proofsome movies don't live up to expectations (Lions for Lambs, Rendition) and some exceed them (Juno, Gone Baby Gone)but most of the time our early Best Picture suspicisions are validated with at least some nominations, if not wins (Cold Mountain, Munich, Atonement). Therefore, purely for fun, here is a rundown, in alphabetical order, of the films that I suspect will be key players in the 2008 Oscar race, with my best-guess final five listed at the end...


APPALOOSA (TBA, New Line)
Oscar nominated actor Ed Harris adapted, directed, and co-stars in this western with Oscar nominee Viggo Mortensen as a marshal and deputy in the Old West who attempt to restore order to a town that is suffering under the rule of a ruthless rancher (played Oscar winner Jeremy Irons) who murdered the previous marshal and deputy. The new lawmen arrest the rancher, but hired guns help him escape, prompting a long pursuit that leads to an inevitable showdown. Will the marshal return to the young, piano-playing widow (Oscar winner Renee Zellweger) who has won his heart, or will evil prevail?


THE ARGENTINE and GUERILLA (both TBA, Focus Features)
Under the watchful eyes of Oscar winning director Steven Soderbergh, Oscar winning actor Benicio Del Toro brings Che Guevara back to life in these two films
think Flags of Our Fathers and Letters from Iwo Jima... only Communist! In the first film, Guevara and Fidel Castro lead a band of Cuban exiles who in 1956 overthrew of U.S.-friendly Cuban dictator Fulgencio Batista. Early photos of and buzz about Del Toro hint that his performance may be one for the ages. (Oscar nominee Catalina Sandino Moreno and Benjamin Bratt also star.) In the second film, which I see as less likely, Guevara travels to New York City to address the United Nations.


AUSTRALIA (11/14, 20th Century Fox)
This epic film reunites Moulin Rouge director Bazz Luhrmann and Oscar winner Nicole Kidman, along with fellow Aussie Hugh Jackman, in a story of one woman's personal struggle intersecting with a national struggle during World War II after the Japanese, shortly after bombing Pearl Harbor, began bombing Darwin, Australia. The script was penned by Oscar winner Ronald Harwood. The essential question: will this be what Cold Mountain was or what it could have been?


BLINDNESS (8/8, Miramax)
City of God director Fernando Meirelles directs this big screen adaptation of Nobel Prize winner Jose Saramago's popular novel about a tragic illness that afflicts all but one member of a small town. It stars past Oscar nominee Julianne Moore (who is long overdue for a win), Mark Ruffalo (who is long overdue to be a star), Gael Garcia Bernal, Danny Glover, and Sandra Oh.


BODY OF LIES (10/10, Warner Brothers)
The first time Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe worked together, Scott earned a Best Director nomination, Crowe a Best Actor win, and their film, Gladiator, won Best Picture. The second and third times were for A Good Year and American Gangster, and neither got any Oscar love. This fourth film, adapted from David Ignatius' novel about a journalist injured in the ongoing war in Iraq who is then hired by the CIA to track down and kill an al Qaeda terrorist, may get them back on track... particularly since Oscar nominee Leonardo DiCaprio is also involved. Then again, this year's Oscar nominees show the Academy has little taste for Iraq-related features, so who knows?


THE CHANGELING (11/7, Universal)
Directed by Clint Eastwood, this mystery film stars Oscar winner Angelina Jolie as the mother of a kidnapped child. When the child is returned home, it quickly becomes apparent that it is not the same child that went missing. Oscar nominees John Malkovich and Amy Ryan also star. The film sounds a tad too supernatural, but would Oscar-magnet Eastwood really waste his time on something unworthy?

THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON (12/19, Paramount)
David Fincher is one of the most talented directors of his generation, and this may be the vehicle to finally demonstrate that to a wide audience. Oscar winning screenwriter Eric Roth adapted F. Scott Fitzgerald's short story of a man who starts aging backwards, Brad Pitt stars as the man, and Oscar winners Cate Blanchett and Tilda Swinton are also along for the ride. The tone Fincher takes with the film
too serious? too lightweight?will determine whether or not it has the stuff Oscars are made of.

DEFIANCE (TBA, Paramount Vantage)
Oscar winner Edward Zwick directs this original screenplay of three Jewish brothers
Daniel Craig (of James Bond fame), Liev Schreiber, and Jamie Bellwho escape from Nazi-occupied Poland into the forests of Belarus, where they join the Russian resistance. Zwick's past drama/war films have been received by the Academy both warmly (Glory) and coldly (The Last Samurai), so it's a gamble, but a film about the Holocaust and the resistance movement has a lot of potential.

DOUBT (12/5, Miramax)
John Patrick Shanley, the noted playwright and Oscar winning screenwriter (Moonstruck), has penned the script and directed his Pulitzer Prize winning play Doubt for the big screen, with Oscar winners Meryl Streep and Philip Seymour Hoffman and Oscar nominee Amy Adams headlining an impressive cast. The story, set at a Catholic school in New York
in 1964, centers around a nun who suspects a priest of abusing a young black student, and must now decide how to respond. It film raises serious questions about religion, morality, and authority that could either prove compelling... or preachy, like this year's dud Lions for Lambs. It will all come down to how well Shanley can truly 'adapt' his work for a different medium... with the assistance of producer Scott Rudin, its prospects look bright.

FROST/NIXON (TBA, Universal)
Peter Morgan, who recently won accolades for writing The Queen, here adapts his own Broadway smash-hit into a film directed by Oscar winner Ron Howard and starring actors' actors Frank Langella and Michael Sheen (both from the play). The film recounts a series of dramatic post-Watergate interviews that ex-President Richard Nixon granted to British television reporter David Frost. (The film also features Kevin Bacon, Matthew Macfayden, Oliver Platt, and Sam Rockwell.)

MILK (11/TBA, Focus Features)
In a bio-pic that is sure to provoke controversy and attention, Oscar winner Sean Penn will be portraying Harvey Milk, the civil rights activist whose election as one of San Francisco's city supervisors made him the first openly-gay man to hold a prominent political office, and who was struck down in his prime by an assassin's bullets. The team behind American Beauty are producing, Oscar nominee Gus Van Sant is directing, and the rest of the cast includes Penn's Into the Wild protegee Emile Hirsch and No Country's Josh Brolin, both among the snubees of the 2007 awards season, as well as Diego Luna, Victor Garber, and James Franco as Milk's lover.

THE READER (12/12, The Weinstein Company)
Studio chiefs Bob and Harvey Weinstein must be foaming at the mouth
for the decade-plus they ran Miramax, they picked up Oscars like most of us pick up groceries, but since they went independent they have struggled mightily. This sounds like their return to form, though, as it re-pairs The Hours Oscar nominated writer David Hare, director Stephen Daldry, and producer Scott Rudin, and stars two of the best actors in the business, Kate Winslet and Ralph Fiennes, both of whom are both long-overdue for Oscars. Set in post-WWII Germany, it is the story of a young man's decades-long obsession with an older woman coming to a head during a war crimes trial.

REVOLUTIONARY ROAD (12/19, Paramount Vantage)
Richard Yates' admired debut novel from 1961 (one of Time magazine's 100 best since 1923) is finally being brought to the screen in a film
produced by Scott Rudin, directed by Oscar winner Sam Mendes, and starring Kate Winslet (Mendes' wife) and Leonardo DiCaprio, together again for the first time since their characters went down and they shot up with Titanic. Eleven years later, they are portraying a young married couple in 1950s suburban Connecticut whose hopes and dreams of an above-average life (at a time when most hoped to be average) are painfully thwarted, throwing their family into chaos. Oscar winner Kathy Bates also stars.

SEVEN POUNDS (12/12, Sony)
Two-time Oscar nominated actor Will Smith is back in the race for the first time since The Pursuit of Happyness (2005). He has re-teamed with the director of that film, Gabriele Muccino to tell the story of a guilt-stricken man on the verge of suicide who is inspired to try to begin life anew thanks to a meeting with a caring woman (Rosario Dawson). In the course of attempting to make amends for the past and find meaning in the future, he changes the lives of seven strangers. Woody Harrellson and Barry Pepper also appear.

THE SOLOIST (TBA, DreamWorks)
Oscar nominated screenwriter Susannah Grant (Erin Brokovich) wrote a script based on the true story of Nathaniel Ayers, who was a violin prodigy before developing schizophrenia and winding up homeless and living on the streets of Skid Row.
Joe Wright has directed Oscar winner Jamie Foxx as Ayers and Robert Downey, Jr. as the Los Angeles Times columnist who discovered him and told the world his story. Oscar nominee Catherine Keener and Tom Hollander also appear.

SYNECDOCHE, NEW YORK (TBA, TBA)
Oscar winner Charlie Kauffman, argubaly the most talented writer in the business today, both wrote and
for the first timedirected this film, which stars Oscar winners Philip Seymour Hoffman and Dianne Weist, Oscar nominees Catherine Keener, Samantha Morton, Emily Watson, and Michelle Williams, and the long-overdue Hope Davis and Jennifer Jason Leigh. Kauffman's films (most notably Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind) are known for their eccentric charms, and this one will probably be no exceptionit centers around a theater director (Hoffman) whose life is crumbling around him as he mounts his latest production.

THE TIME TRAVELER'S WIFE (11/TBA, New Line)
The Notebook screenwriter Jeremy Leven has adapted another romantic comedy. This film will star Rachel McAdams (who got her big break on the former film) and Eric Bana as a married couple with a slight problem... he has a gene that causes him to involuntarily travel in time. Obviously, this could very easily be The Lake House, but a part of me thinks it might be something special, especially considering that both stars are among the most talented young people in the industry.

THE YOUNG VICTORIA (TBA, TBA)
Oscar winning screenwriter Julian Fellowes (Gosford Park) would seem to be in his element penning another British period piece, this time focusing on the early years in the life and reign of Queen Victoria, who rose to the throne at the age of 18, guided the British Empire at its height, and reigned for 64 years
until her death—which was the longest period of any British monarch until Queen Elizabeth II surpassed it in 2007. It is rumored that Emily Blunt (The Devil Wears Prada), overseen by French director Jean-Marc Vallee, has delivered a remarkable performance. Rupert Friend (Pride and Prejudice) portrays her husband, Prince Albert, Oscar winner Jim Broadbent, Oscar nominee Miranda Richardson, and Paul Bettany also appear in the film, and it is of great note that Martin Scorsese and Sarah Ferguson, the Duchess of York, are among the film's producers.


If I had a gun to my head, I would guess that the five Best Picture nominees will wind up being
Australia (20th Century Fox), Defiance (Paramount Vantage), Frost/Nixon (Universal), The Reader (The Weinstein Company), and Revolutionary Road (Focus Features), with The Young Victoria (TBA) as my alternate, and The Reader edging out Revolutionary Road (Winslet v. Winslet?) for the win. Granted, all of this will probably look very funny when we get to that point many months from now...

Posted by Editor at 22:41:46 | Permanent Link | Comments (38) |
Comments
1 - Defiance? Are you kidding me? It's from Edward Zwick, the same guy who directed such melodramatic nonsense as Blood Diamond and Glory.

There goes one prediction out the window. Oh, and I wouldn't count on Australia, either. (Comment this)

Written by: Robert Hamer at 2008/02/26 - 03:08:52
2 - Haha nice to have you back, Robert. So who WILL be nominated then? (Comment this)

Written by: Scott Feinberg at 2008/02/26 - 03:15:11
3 - Just to be in form. Here is mine very early predictions

PICTURE
Curious case of Benjamin Button
Appaloosa
Revolutionary road
Changeling
Mammoth

DIRECTOR
David Fincher for The Curious case of Benjamin Button
Ed Harris for Appaloosa
Clint Eastwood for The Changeling
Lukas Moodysson for Mammoth
Baz Luhrman for Australia

ACTOR
Brad Pitt for The Curious case…
Viggo Mortensen for Appaloosa
Sean Penn for Milk
Alan Alda for Diminished Capacity
Benicio Del Toro for The Argentina

ACTRESS
Julianna Moore for Blindness
Michelle Williams for Mammoth
Meryl Streep for Doubt
Angelina Jolie for The Changeling
Anna Paquin for Margaret

SUPPORTING ACTOR
Jamie Bell for Defiance
Lance Henriksen for Appaloosa
Diego Luna for Rudy i Cursy
John Malkovich for The Changeling
Ralph Fiennes for The Reader

SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Dakota Fanning for Winged Creatures
Sandra Oh for Blindness
Emma Thompson for Brideshead revisited
Frances Macdormand for Burn after reading
Catherine Keener for Synecdoche New York

ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
Appaloosa
Curious case of Benjamin Button
Blindness
Revolutionary road
Winged Creatures

ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
The Changeling
Mammoth
The Argentine
Synecdoche, New York
Franklyn

ANIMATED FEATURE
Wall-e
Horton hears a who!
Igor




 (Comment this)

Written by: BigRussian at 2008/02/26 - 03:39:40
4 - Not too many european actors this time, heh ??

And what about "Public Enemies", with Johnny Depp, Christian Bale and.....the unforgiven and unforgetable Marion Cotillard ?

Will be released too late for oscars next year ? (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/02/26 - 04:53:42
5 - Good rundown. But Gus Van Sant didn't direct "L.A. Confidential," Curtis Hanson did. (Comment this)

Written by: Matthew Lucas at 2008/02/26 - 05:37:46
6 - I would predict that the next Best Picture nominees are Body of Lies (what can I say, I'm hoping Sir Scott finally gets his due), Blindness, Milk, Revolutionary Road, and The Soloist, with The Reader as my alternate. My criticism of Autralia and Defiance is due to the lack of talent of their directors.

I also *guarantee* at least a Best Makeup and Best Costume Design nomination for The Dark Knight. I also hope that Jon Stewart will be asked back for a third time, because he was great this year! There, I said it. (Comment this)

Written by: Robert Hamer at 2008/02/26 - 05:54:13
7 - I predict Time Travelers Wife will strike a chord with audiences this year. A film whose very essence is about trying to maintain a state of normalacy in a sureal world sounds just about right. Of course my guess is as good as anyones. (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/02/26 - 17:00:13
8 - Nice overview. I didn't even know Revolutionary Road was coming out this year.

I don't have faith in Blindness, mostly because it's written by Don McKeller, whose movies are usually so obtuse and dry... he just seems like a bad fit for Fernando M. (I'm too lazy to even try to butcher his name). Plus, Mark Ruffalo is death at the Oscars. I like the guy, I like his acting, I like his personality, but everything he does just seems to whiff come awards time (Eternal Sunshine, Zodiac, Reservation Road, We Don't Live Here Anymore).

I have hope for The Young Victoria. Director Jean-Marc Vallee is destined for great things. His french-language flick C.R.A.Z.Y. was a huge hit here in Canada a few years ago and for good reason. He has a knack for storytelling and C.R.A.Z.Y. was easily one of the most original movies I've seen in the past ten years.

I wonder if the Che flicks will have a Flags/Iwo Jima dynamic, or if they'll simply cancel each other out come awards time.

Very early prediction: The Reader will win Best Picture. It seems like the type of movie appalled voters will run to after the vulgar bloodshed of No Country and Departed. (Comment this)

Written by: Vance H.G. Gillis at 2008/02/26 - 17:27:18
9 - Wall.E a best picture nominee?
 (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/02/26 - 18:13:07
10 - Robert, nice defense of your picks.
Matthew, thanks for pointing that out.
And Vance, all excellent points. I'm with you in predicting 'The Young Victoria' to be a much bigger player than anyone is anticipating (Emily Blunt is THAT good--I saw some of her earlier work prior to an interview a few years ago) and also that 'The Reader' strikes me as the best-bet for the win at the outset. Between that or 'Revolutionary Road,' I would think that Kate the Great Winslet has a great chance of FINALLY getting that long overdue Best Actress Oscar.
'Anonymous' posters: please share your names (at least your first names!) so we can all engage in a continuous discussion this year. As for your points, I have a bit of a hard time seeing either 'Time Traveler's Wife' or 'Wall.E' as Best Pic nominees, but you're on the record and I'll stand corrected if proven wrong. (Comment this)

Written by: Scott Feinberg at 2008/02/26 - 21:59:07
11 - Looking forward to seeing them all. Maybe you and your fellow prognosticators will fare better this year. And maybe the Academy will pick better movie than No Country.

AM (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/02/26 - 23:24:14
12 - Let's hope so!! ;) (Comment this)

Written by: Scott Feinberg at 2008/02/26 - 23:51:15
13 - I think Mamma Mia is going to be a player. Besides the fact that it is based on one of the most successful musicals of all time, it stars Meryl Streep, and that almost guarentees it will get Oscar consideration. (Comment this)

Written by: Steven Hughes at 2008/02/27 - 02:17:13
14 - "...it stars Meryl Streep, and that almost guarentees it will get Oscar consideration."

*cough*Lions for Lambs*cough*

"I predict Time Travelers Wife will strike a chord with audiences this year."

Maybe, but the book irritated the hell out of me, and science fiction films have a terrible track record at the Oscars (Ghandi over E.T.? WTF?). That's why I'm also not really too confident about The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Same goes for Blindness *if* it has a sci-fi bent (I haven't read the book).

"Wall.E a best picture nominee?"

Doubt it, although it will almost certainly be nominated for Best Animated Feature.

"...maybe the Academy will pick better movie than No Country."

That'll just have to depend on the quality of the movie, won't it? I mean, it would have to be flawless just like No Country for Old Men and that's just for starters. :) (Comment this)

Written by: Robert Hamer at 2008/02/27 - 02:59:05
15 - Just FYI, I had forgotten to include 'Appaloosa' and have now added it to the mix. (Comment this)

Written by: Scott Feinberg at 2008/02/27 - 04:03:33
16 - If "Sweeney Todd" and "Hairspray" couldn't get nominated, I kinda doubt "Mamma Mia" will. But you never know.

I think "The Argentine" and "Guerilla" will definitely be major players. Watch out for "Guerilla" though, remember when everyone thought "Flags of Our Fathers" was the shoo-in nominee, only to fade and give way to "Letters from Iwo Jima?"

Either way, Del Toro is in. (Comment this)

Written by: Matthew Lucas at 2008/02/27 - 06:32:46
17 - Scott, where did you hear the rumor about Emily Blunt's performance? Someone who worked on the film or someone who saw it (perhaps at the Berlin Festival where it was privately screened)? I remember seeing "My Summer of Love" before "The Devil Wears Prada" even came out and thinking she was one to look out for. Of course with TDWP she showed that as well as her versatility. (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/02/27 - 07:03:37
18 - Seven Pounds with Will Smith (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/02/27 - 07:17:29
19 - oh my name is emad,and i think wall.E will be awesome,if nemo got 93 on metacritic the cute robot will be above 90 at least,and based on the articles on the web suggesting that ratatouille should be a best picture nod i think the academy will have animations reconsidered.
and dont forget shutter island(if it's due 2008)i know mystery is not genre of scorsese,but it's scorsese!
soory for bad english! (Comment this)

Written by: emad at 2008/02/27 - 07:47:20
20 - It's a very long shot but what about Prince Caspian. The first one was the closest we've had to another LOTR and the trailer for Prince Caspian looks like it's on the level that LOTR was on. (Comment this)

Written by: Steven Hughes at 2008/02/27 - 14:56:57
21 - I *highly* doubt Prince Caspian will have a great showing at next year's Oscars. For one thing, Prince Caspian is perhaps the weakest book in the Narnia series; C.S. Lewis basically used it as a platform to attack secularism, with little regard for plot or character development. Even if it was "on the level" of The Lord of the Rings (which I wouldn't count on), this isn't 2001, where an epic fantasy like LOTR was practically unprecedented. Today, we've seen Narnia, Spiderwick Chronicles, Harry Potter, Eragon, The Dark is Rising, and His Dark Materials brought to the big screen. What could Prince Caspian possibly bring to the genre that those other films haven't? From what I've seen of the trailer, nothing. (Comment this)

Written by: Robert Hamer at 2008/02/27 - 17:40:17
22 - All right, I'll play. My predictions:

BEST PICTURE

Doubt
Frost/Nixon
The Reader
Revolutionary Road
The Young Victoria

BEST DIRECTOR

Ed Harris, Appaloosa
Clint Eastwood, The Changeling
John Patrick Shanley, Doubt
Stephen Daldry, The Reader
Sam Mendes, Revolutionary Road

BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY

The Young Victoria
The Changeling
Appaloosa
The Soloist
Synecdoche, New York

BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Revolutionary Road
The Reader
Blindness
Doubt

BEST ACTRESS

Julianna Moore, Blindness
Kate Winslet, Revolutionary Road
Meryl Streep, Doubt
Emily Blunt, The Young Victoria
Michelle Williams, Mammoth

BEST ACTOR

Sean Penn, Milk
Brad Pitt, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Philip Seymour Hoffman, Doubt
Frank Langella, Frost/Nixon
John Malkovich, The Changeling

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS

Sandra Oh, Blindness
Cate Blanchett, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Amy Adams, Doubt
Kathy Bates, Revolutionary Road
Catherine Kenner, Synecdoche, New York

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR

Ralph Fiennes, The Reader
Mark Ruffalo, Blindness
Jamie Bell, Defiance
Kevin Bacon, Frost/Nixon
Jim Broadbent, The Young Victoria (Comment this)

Written by: Gayla at 2008/02/28 - 07:28:39
23 - Gayla,

Kevin Bacon for "Front/Nixon?" I think Michael Sheen probably has a better shot, especially after his snubbing for "The Queen." (Comment this)

Written by: Matthew Lucas at 2008/02/29 - 02:43:32
24 - Well, I had to throw in one totally off-the-wall guess. But you make a good point about Michael Sheen; I'd forgotten he was snubbed before. (Comment this)

Written by: Gayla at 2008/02/29 - 07:11:06
25 - The Road (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/03/01 - 01:01:31
26 - And whatever Alfonso Cuaron's next project is... (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/03/01 - 01:03:50
27 - What is Mammoth about? (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/03/01 - 03:20:12
28 - From IMDB: "While on a trip to Thailand, a successful American businessman tries to radically change his life. Back in New York, his wife and daughter find their relationship with their live-in Filipino maid changing around them. At the same time, in the Philippines, the maid's family struggles to deal with her absence." (Comment this)

Written by: Gayla at 2008/03/01 - 08:19:20
29 - "BABEL: THAILAND EDITION" haha (Comment this)

Written by: Scott Feinberg at 2008/03/01 - 13:16:15
30 - "Mammoth" = bad title coming after "10,000 BC."

Not something the team behind "Mammoth" wants to be associated with, I think. (Comment this)

Written by: Matthew Lucas at 2008/03/02 - 08:17:49
31 - Public Enemies, Lovely Bones & Shutter Island are all due out next year.

I have a bad feeling about Austrailia.

Forgot
The Road
Miracle at St. Anna-Spike Lee is overdue, but this is also a Sci- Fi flick ( if it is like the book).

 (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/03/04 - 00:49:58
32 - "Revolutionary Road" certainly has the pedigree...but why am I getting a "Charlie Wilson's War" vibe off of our pre-ordained front-runner? (Comment this)

Written by: Matthew Lucas at 2008/03/04 - 02:27:49
33 - got no idea for best picture because there always seems to be something that comes out of nowhere in the noms (little miss sunshine, juno, the coen brothers actually winning for a stark, dark, western thriller) but a few things worth mentioning:

as will smith once said, in recent years it's been pretty much a guarantee that the winner of best actor is either playing someone insane or a historical figure (daniel day lewis as daniel plainview, forrest whitaker as idi amin, phillip seymour hoffman as truman capote etc.). Benicio del toro has both in the bag as che guevara and, especially in not one but two soderbergh films, i think he's guaranteed a definite nomination and a likely win

for screenplay, synechdoche ny is surely going to be the most deserved so will probably get a nomination. i think we can't ignore burn after reading. the coen brothers just won 3 oscars including best pic, so i think they can probably expect a nomination for at least screenplay. also, the wackness, which won audience at sundance, looks like just the kind of quirky indie comedy to do just well enough for a screenplay nom (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/03/07 - 03:52:49
34 - I don't know why you have Appaloosa up there. If 3:10 To Yuma couldn't get a nomination, how can Appaloosa have any shot? I highly doubt that it will be anywhere near as good as Yuma. (Comment this)

Written by: Steven Hughes at 2008/03/09 - 07:16:17
35 - Revolutionary Road will I wait for the most.
 (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/03/21 - 23:41:23
36 - Does anybody know anything about the movie called "brothers' with Jake Gyllenhall, Tobey Maguire and Natalie Portman? (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/04/03 - 13:23:58
37 - Benjamin Button & Revolutionary Road both strike me as very, very unlikely contenders. Fincher's previous efforts have not impressed the Academy. His fanboys are fanatical in their adoration of him but this hasn't translated into any real world awards affection. The title evokes an air of rather arch whimsy. Can Fincher do whimsy? Nothing in his previous work has suggested he can so my guess is this is yet another dark, dreary drama that'll ultimately go nowhere. As for 'Revolutionary Road' is it the title that turns its fans on & makes them think it's Oscar material? Do they get a thrill from typing out the word 'revolutionary'? Because whatever the reason the fact is the synopsis sounds deeply boring & the whispers about a lousy performance from Winslett are troubling. I sense another 'Good Shepherd' in the making.

'Australia' sounds equally uninteresting (WW2-era movies aren't popular & I'm sceptical that merely transplanting them to the other side of the world is going to make any difference). Hugh Jackman also looks severely miscast. Shouldn't he be more, erm, rugged? Speaking of miscast the winner here has to be Sean Penn as Harvey Milk. Having seen the original documentary I'm amazed at the complete lack of resemblance between actor & subject & worse, the kind of vibe that Penn gives off as an actor gives me no faith that he can capture the qualities that made Milk so popular. In fact think this could be a seriously embarrassing misfire for Penn & his director. Obviously I'd like to be wrong but every time I look at the photos of him I can hear the alarm bells ringing.

All in all, if you're really lucky, you might find that one of those on your list emerges as a key player come Oscar time. FWIW I think that's likely to be one (or both!) of the Eastwood pics. (Comment this)

Written by: Anonymous at 2008/04/03 - 14:03:49
38 - APALOOSA--this will be one helluva western. i think harris, mortenson and zellwegger will IMRPOVE on an already engaging story by the specifics they bring to making their characters LIVE! that is the trademark of both harris and mortenson--and zellwegger will benefit from playing with her costars... APALOOSA WILL BE THE HIT OF THE SEASON! (Comment this)

Written by: wish at 2008/04/25 - 01:16:24
Write a comment